Shinzo Abe: A Powerful Yet Polarizing Figure

Abe was held in high esteem in the West for his promotion of Japanese-American ties. However, Abe was also a controversial figure in the Indo-Pacific region for his revisionism of Japanese war crimes


4 min read
Shinzo Abe: A Powerful Yet Polarizing Figure

By: Bonnie Vanguardia

Japan’s former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe was killed in Nara City on July 8, marking one of  the most high-profile assassinations in recent times. It was a tragedy that nobody could have  anticipated—especially in a country where gun violence is nearly negligible—and has deeply  shaken Japanese society.

As leader of the Liberal Democratic Party, Abe was the nation’s longest-serving Prime  Minister and one of its strongest since World War Two, initiating policies which led to the  overhaul of its defence system. His time in office saw an increase in military spending, the  establishment of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue with India, Australia and the United  States, and an impressive revision to Japan’s pacifist constitution that now enables its military  to fight alongside foreign allies.

His death leaves behind many questions regarding Japanese security, but for foreign policy  analysts one question remains unanswered: What is Abe’s legacy in global politics?

As world leaders moved quickly to pay their respects to the ex-Prime Minister, it was his fostering of stronger East-West ties that stood out to them the most. “He was a champion of  the Alliance between our nations and the friendship between our people,” U.S. President Joe  Biden wrote in a statement released by the White House, “his vision of a free and open Indo Pacific will endure”.

Indeed, Abe has always been a staunch defender of U.S.-Japanese relations during and after his Prime Ministership. He continually reaffirmed their joint commitment to Taiwanese  security during periodical Chinese aggression and, more boldly, authorised the construction  of an American military base in Okinawa against local protests. His tenure also saw the  signing of the US-Japan Trade Agreement, lifting tariffs on certain products from 2019 and  strengthening economic ties.

Such actions leave little doubt as to why he is being remembered as a friend of the West. In  fact, others have gone further than simply recognising Abe as an American or Western ally,  with political commentator David Frum claiming that the former leader of Japan was “one of  the great internationalists of his era’”.

But Abe’s reputation in the Asia-Pacific region tells a different story.

Despite being hailed as a defender of democracy, Abe held a controversial stance on Japan’s  war crimes during World War Two. Critics maintain that he downplayed the brutalities  committed by the Imperial Japanese Army, a topic that remains taboo in Japan. After all, the ex-Prime Minister never shied away from his alternative views.

During his first term in office, he claimed that there was insufficient evidence of comfort  women being forced into sexual submission, suggesting that they were prostitutes as opposed  to sex slaves. He would also make several visits to the Yasukuni Shrine during his lifetime, a  place where 14 convicted Japanese war criminals are buried, drawing much controversy in  countries like South Korea.

His interpretation of history would later dominate the Japanese school system. In 2013  educational reforms began altering depictions of the imperial army in classes, with Abe

instituting textbook screenings to prevent overly negative portrayals of his country. One of  the topics revised included accounts of sexual slavery, requiring a disclaimer that they were  ‘disputed’—much to the frustration of historians and victims alike.

However, Abe did not only seek to alter the national memory. His attempts to impose a  different account of events reached various states in Asia, namely the countries which had  suffered under Japanese oppression.

In 2017 Tokyo recalled two of its diplomats to South Korea, citing its erection of a statue  dedicated to Korean rape victims in Japanese brothels. Yoshihide Suga, then Cabinet  Secretary and later Abe’s successor, stated that South Korea had failed to “deal with the  resolution of this issue appropriately”. The incident only enflamed existing hostilities  between the two states, forcing historical grievances to resurface. Ever since, relations between Japan and South Korea have remained in a political backwater.

Then, in 2019 the Japanese Government pressured Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte into  taking down a statue commemorating their nation’s comfort women. The President could not  deny the request, given Japan was the Philippines’ largest contributor of overseas  development assistance at the time. Women’s rights activists protested the statue’s removal,  with Philippine academic Teresita Ang See claiming that “good relations with Japan should  not come at the expense of forgetting history”. The statue was only on display for five  months.

Strained relations between these states and Japan did not rest solely on Abe’s revisionism.  But with anti-Japan protests continuing in South Korea today and the Philippines’ new government shifting towards China, Abe’s war on words must be recognised as worsening  ties with other Indo-Pacific countries. He may have brought Japan closer to the West, but  Japan seems more alienated now than ever to several of its democratic neighbours.

Shinzo Abe will certainly go down in history for his ambitious foreign policy goals. But like  the hugely varied views of Japanese history books, he will be portrayed positively in some  and negatively in others.

Bibliography:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/24/okinawa-referendum-rejects-new-us military-base-but-abe-likely-to-press-on

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/12/2/china-summons-japanese-ambassador-over-abes taiwan-comments

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/12/01/japan-us-could-not-stand-by-if-china-attacked-taiwan shinzo-abe-.html

https://www.mofa.go.jp/files/000470871.pdf

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-54216632

https://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/29/world/asia/japan-fights-a-political-battle-using-history texts.html

https://www.voanews.com/a/japan-s-abe-brought-lasting-change-to-country-s-defense approach-/6650690.html

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/07/shinzo-abe-japanese-prime-minister assassination/661523/

https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/07/08/statement-by president-biden-on-the-killing-of-former-japanese-prime-minister-abe-shinzo/

https://www.dw.com/en/japan-recalls-ambassador-suspends-talks-with-south-korea-over comfort-woman-statue/a-37033180

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/986146/removal-of-comfort-woman-statue-draws-protest


S2E11: Policy for Aging Populations
Previous article

S2E11: Policy for Aging Populations

Kate and Colin Busby, the Director of Policy and Outreach at HEC Montréal, discuss public policies for aging populations: from healthcare and financing to retirement and the impacts of inflation, Voice Above provides a deep dive into a policy field that affects all of us.

Russia’s Gas War Threatens EU Unity
Next article

Russia’s Gas War Threatens EU Unity

The EU has responded by proposing strict gas rationing on all 27 member states. However, the strategy has generated much controversy and resistance among its southernmost members.


Related Articles

Moving Ontarians More Safely Act
2 min read
Haiti Was Never Even Given a Chance
14 min read
Weighing the Scale
2 min read

GO TOP

🎉 You've successfully subscribed to Youth In Politics!
OK